We had a break through moment today.. Phoebe actualy went and stood by the back door to go out. I asked her if she needed to go outside and she came running to me. I started to take another bite of cereal and she yipped at me. So I got up right away and took her out. She did her business as soon as she got outside!!! Yay one for Phoebe! I was just so proud. It is now afternoon and she has had no accidents inside!!!